The age-old (er—the year-old) question that has haunted The Summer I Turned Pretty fans since the day the show first came out. For OG fans of the book trilogy, the debate has lasted far longer. Are you falling for Conrad's mysterious persona or dreaming of a date with Jere? TBH, you could be crushing on another TSITP boy altogether.

There's plenty of Cousins Beach boys to fall for, but what does your choice say about you? Conrad and Jeremiah are polar opposites—and, not to mention the adorable Cam and mischevious Steven.

We're breaking down exactly what your obsession that one TSITP boy means for your love life IRL. Hold on to your hats, Conrad girlies.

If you're Team Cameron...

You're a girl with a soft heart and a penchant for good conversation. From the first time Belly meets Cam Cameron (AKA Sextus) in the very first episode of season one, she's totally charmed by his adorably nerdy persona. And, honestly, so were we.

If you find yourself crushing on Cam, you probs want a low-drama relationship. Cam says it like it is, but always wants what's best for you. You prioritize authentic love and are always up to talk about your obscure obsessions (Latin convention, anybody?). Bonus points if you can cook some mean vegetarian dishes to share with your eco-conscious bae.

@thesummeriturnedpretty

If you're team Steven...

You're a girl who admires dedication, intelligence and a healthy dose of wit. Steven is our fave Ivy League-bound boy, destined to attend a college like Princeton through his hard work. But DW, he'll never back down from a good time—his BFF Jeremiah makes sure of that.

If you like Steven, you're likely looking for someone who balances responsibility with leisure. Steven will always make time to study for his next exam *and* get down on the dance floor. Not to mention his protective instincts. If he cares for us the way he cares for Belly, we'd have no complaints, TBH.

@thesummeriturnedpretty

If you're team Jeremiah...

You're a girl who will fall head over heels for charisma. Jere is the life of the party—he's got that bubbly, golden retriever energy that makes everyone feel like they're best friends with him. He may have a flirtatious personality, but it's his carefree attitude that makes him all the more attractive.

Team Jeremiah gals crave someone who's gonna dance like nobody's watching at a party (with you, of course!). Maybe you're not as outgoing yourself, but Jere's personality would compliment your vibes perfectly. You're looking for something definite and a little lovey-dovey. Straight out of a love story, yk?

@thesummeriturnedpretty

If you're team Conrad...

You're in love with the idea of love... but you might like the thrill of the chase a little more. Conrad keeps you on your toes. One second, he's almost professing his love, and the next second he's pretending you don't exist. He's a whirlwind of emotion, but let's be real: You fall for each new side of him you discover.

You might be happy with a Jeremiah, but you'll never forget a Conrad. Tall and mysterious, a Conrad brings spontanaeity...and you secretly enjoy looking for that elusive soft spot they have for you. Alexa, play "Midnight Rain" by Taylor Swift.

@thesummeriturnedpretty